The Do-Over: Why Massachusetts Is Retrying Lindsay Clancy (And Should They?)

1 hr 4 min

Eleven of twelve jurors were ready to find Lindsay Clancy not guilty by reason of insanity. In Massachusetts, the state has to prove a defendant was sane. It didn’t. So the Plymouth County DA is trying her again: same first-degree charges, new jury, March 29th, your money.

This week I’m asking whether she should be tried again at all. We get into the history of the insanity defense, seven American cases where very sick people got a hospital, prison, or the death chamber, what this retrial is going to cost, and the best arguments for retrying her, which I take apart one by one. Then we finish with the warning signs of postpartum psychosis.

Lindsay Clancy is charged, pleaded not guilty, and hasn’t been convicted.

Thank you for keeping this show independent.

f you or someone you love needs help: In an emergency, call 911 or go to the nearest ER. National Maternal Mental Health Hotline: call or text 1-833-TLC-MAMA (1-833-852-6262), 24/7. In a crisis, call or text 988.

Support the Show

Help fund the research, the receipts, and the mic time.